Authoring tool comparison

Storyline vs Captivate: which should you use?

PCG generally recommends Storyline over Captivate for serious custom eLearning because Storyline is easier to design in, easier to maintain, and stronger for polished interaction work. PCG can also convert older Captivate courses into Storyline.

Our recommendation at a glance

  • Storyline is PCG’s preferred authoring tool for custom interaction, simulations, and learner-focused course design.
  • Captivate may appear in legacy course libraries, but many organizations benefit from converting those courses into Storyline.
  • A Storyline rebuild is often the right move when a course needs better usability, cleaner visuals, or easier long-term updates.

Why Storyline is the better default

Storyline gives instructional designers and developers a stronger environment for building interactions, branching scenarios, simulations, variables, feedback, and branded course interfaces. It also supports the kind of custom learner experience PCG builds for clients.

For most teams, the question is not whether a course can technically be built in Captivate. The better question is whether the course will be easy to use, easy to update, and strong enough to support real learner practice.

Interactive course interface shown on multiple devices
Interactive course interfaces show the flexibility available for modern custom eLearning.

Where Captivate usually appears

Captivate often shows up in older training libraries, software demos, or legacy courses that need repair. Those courses may still function, but they can be harder to maintain and may feel dated compared with modern Storyline development.

When clients come to PCG with Captivate material, the best answer is often a thoughtful conversion to Storyline rather than another round of patchwork.

When to convert Captivate to Storyline

Conversion makes sense when the course needs a visual refresh, better interaction, accessibility review, LMS republishing, improved mobile behavior, or easier editing. It also makes sense when internal teams no longer want to maintain Captivate files.

PCG can preserve the useful source content while rebuilding the course structure, interface, activities, feedback, and publishing package in Storyline.

New builds versus legacy conversions

Start with Storyline for new custom eLearning. Convert Captivate courses to Storyline when the course still has value but the format is holding it back.

That gives your training program a cleaner foundation for future updates and a better experience for learners.

Need help applying this to a real project?

Send the project goal, audience, materials, timeline, and review needs. PCG can recommend a realistic path forward.

Request an Estimate